MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua XL Eye Pencil – Review and Swatches

I’ve been seeing these new eyeliners EVERYWHERE, lately.  On the internet, at Sephora, on my friends.  I saw them even more from everybody’s Generation Beauty hauls (Is this the “FOMO” that people talk about?).

make up for ever aqual xl eyeliner review swatches 1

I’ve heard such good things about this collection, but I’m a difficult customer when it comes to eyeliner.

Enter MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua XL Eye Pencil.  A collaboration between MAKE UP FOR EVER and Charli XCX, that contains a collection of waterproof eyeliners that come in a variety of colours and finishes.

Available in 20 shades to match any style, from polished to punk, the AQUA XL Eye Pencil is an artistic collection of eye-popping, ultra-long-lasting eye pencils. Featuring eyeliners in five different finishes – Matte, Diamond, Satin, Iridescent, and Metallic – AQUA XL Eye Pencil was tested by professional makeup artists in extreme conditions: under water, on stage, and on camera. Showcasing a full range of electrifying eye candy looks, from iridescent pastel pink and yellow, to vibrant purple, green and blue, these highly pigmented, high-performance pencils glide on rich and smooth with a special formula to rock any look, day or night. 

make up for ever aqua xl eyeliner review swatches

The AQUA XL Eye Pencil features an exclusive, extra-long (XL) lasting formula, providing:  

XL Performance: A unique blend of ingredients – flexible resin for long-lasting results, vegetable wax for consistent colour payoff, and a revolutionary dry oil that locks in the color and creates water resistance – guarantees waterproof, smudge-proof, transfer-proof and sweat-proof results  

XL Colour: Unique, translucent, crystal copolymer gels helps amplify color intensity and brightness 

XL Comfort: Emollient oil and microspherical silica provides an easy, creamy and smooth application. Mango butter helps prevent skin dryness on application and throughout the day 

make up for ever aqua xl eyeliner review arm swatches me-42 m-30 s-50 m-92 d-62

The waterline test:  As previously mentioned, I’m a tough person to please when it comes to eyeliner.  Nothing, and I mean NOTHING will stay in my waterline for more than 3 minutes.  So of course, I was hoping that the XL Aqua Liners would do the trick.  I put a nice coat of M-92 (lilac purple) in my waterline and hoped for the best.  After 2 minutes the colour disappeared in the outer corner of my waterline, and 3 minutes after that the same happened in the inner corner of my waterline.  There was definitely still a noticeable amount of product in the centre of my waterline, so I’ll attribute the immediate disintegration of the product to not being able to wait for the product to set (you know….needing to blink and all).  The remaining product remained on my waterline for a little over an hour, which may not seem like much, but for me (the waterline makeup murderer) it was pretty impressive.

make up for ever aqual xl eyeliner review swatches face
Wearing ME-42.  Also wearing Anastasia Beverly Hills Maya Mia Palette, theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer, Rimmel Apocalips ‘Light Year’.

While I’m always on the search for something that will stay in my waterline, the main way I use eyeliner is to line my upper lash line, which these liners did beautifully.  The pigmentation was so impressive, and although the product did transfer onto my lashes during application, I didn’t care.  THEY DIDN’T BUDGE.  They stayed for hours.  Even after swatching them on my arm, after 5 minutes I tried to smudge it with my finger, and the swatches looked good as new, even after aggressively trying to rub them away.

make up for ever aqua xl eyeliner review swatches me-42

In addition to the staying power and how pretty the colours look (ME-42 is my absolutely fave), I really like the variety of this collection.  With 20 colours, and 5 different finishes, you are sure to find something that suits your needs – bright pastels, subdued neutrals, bold metallics, etc.  After trying out these eyeliners, I could happily toss out all my other eye pencils and replace them all with the Aqua XL Eye Pencils. 

The MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua XL Eye Pencil are available for $25 CAD/$21 USD at Sephora stores and online.

Press samples featured


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclosure Policy

All products are purchased with personal funds, unless otherwise stated. All opinions are my own.

This policy is valid from December 18, 2014

This blog is a personal blog written and edited by me. For questions about this blog, please contact

This blog accepts free products, services, travel, event tickets, and other forms of compensation from companies and organizations.

The compensation received will never influence the content, topics or posts made in this blog. All advertising is in the form of advertisements generated by a third party ad network. Those advertisements will be identified as paid advertisements.

The views and opinions expressed on this blog are purely the blog owners. If we claim or appear to be experts on a certain topic or product or service area, we will only endorse products or services that we believe, based on our expertise, are worthy of such endorsement. We will accept samples for review consideration, but we do not have to feature everything – it is up to our discretion. Any product claim, statistic, quote or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer or provider.

This blog does not contain any content which might present a conflict of interest.

To get your own policy, go to