Reviews-Day Tuesday ft. Essence Cosmetics: 2-in-1 Eyeliner Pen + Possible High-End Dupe?

Happy Reviews-Day Tuesday, friends!  When I attended the Essence event a few weeks ago (read about it HERE) I was given a very generous goodie bag, with a bunch of the newest releases.  So today is the first of a couple Essence reviews that I will be doing.

Click through, to hear my thoughts, and see swatches of the Essence 2-in-1 eyeliner pen.

“One Eyeliner – two styles!  Whether you’re trying to achieve a fine line for an elegant, classic look or a bold line for a dramatic look – with the essence 2 in 1 eyeliner pen, both are as easy as ABC.”

The pen has 2 sides, one with a thick applicator, and one with a thin one.  I’ll start with the thick end.  The thick end is very firm and has a flat angled edge, which is a great shape to create a cat eye.

Personally, I didn’t like the thick end.  The formula was extremely murky and water-y, and this eye swatch took about 4 layers to try to get close to opacity, which was never actually achieved.  I don’t think that there was anything to rave about, staying-power-wise.  About 2 hours later, the product had really faded – this is how it looked:

Next up is the thin end.  I definitely preferred the thin end, not just due to process of elimination, but because it seemed to have a completely different formula (I don’t know if that’s because it has 2 eyeliners in it, or whether one applicator handles the formula better).  The applicator came down to a very fine tip, and the felt-tip applicator was slightly firm, which I really appreciate – because an uneasy hand, mixed with a flimsy brush applicator can be a dangerous combination.

Now that’s more like it!  There was a consistent black colour throughout the entire swipe, and it was easy to use.  You can use the thin end as a very thin liner, and if you prefer a thick line, I’d suggest to use the thin end, and just build it up.

Essence 2-in-1 eyeliner pen swatched on the back of my hand.

In the hand swatch, pictured above, the thick end is on top, and the thin is on the bottom – huuuge difference.  See how the thick end’s water-y formula poured out into the creases of my skin?  Meanwhile, the thin end stayed put.


– the thin end has great pigmentation

– the thin end has a firm and easy to use applicator (good for beginners)

– for $4.00 – you can’t beat the price


– the thick end’s formula is very water-y

– the thick end does not have lasting staying-power

And just for fun, I compared the thin end of the Essence 2-in-1 eyeliner pen, to my Stila liquid liner.  Can you guess which one is which? ….do I hear “dupe”?

Top:  Essence 2-in-1 eyeliner pen (thin end)
Bottom:  Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner “Intense Black”

In the end, while the thick end didn’t work for me, I was immediately won over by the thin end.  Especially, since other drugstore brands have eyeliners that retail anywhere from $10-$20, and this one only costs a fraction of that price at $4.00, I’d probably collect my loose change and buy this eyeliner in-store, just for the thin end.

Do you have a favourite Essence item?  Do any of their wallet-friendly choices beat out their higher-end counterparts in your beauty regime?  Let me know in the comments below.  Until next time. – Shawna    


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclosure Policy

All products are purchased with personal funds, unless otherwise stated. All opinions are my own.

This policy is valid from December 18, 2014

This blog is a personal blog written and edited by me. For questions about this blog, please contact

This blog accepts free products, services, travel, event tickets, and other forms of compensation from companies and organizations.

The compensation received will never influence the content, topics or posts made in this blog. All advertising is in the form of advertisements generated by a third party ad network. Those advertisements will be identified as paid advertisements.

The views and opinions expressed on this blog are purely the blog owners. If we claim or appear to be experts on a certain topic or product or service area, we will only endorse products or services that we believe, based on our expertise, are worthy of such endorsement. We will accept samples for review consideration, but we do not have to feature everything – it is up to our discretion. Any product claim, statistic, quote or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer or provider.

This blog does not contain any content which might present a conflict of interest.

To get your own policy, go to